A little while ago some chums and I made a TV commercial for a contest (oddly, in that it was 30" and we cut to that, it is now ":60 to Save the Earth" ecospot). Seems we didn't get into the finals. So now it's free to use, here it is:As a creative soul, and in the spirit of unsweetened grapes (it's all how you say it these days), here's my purely subjective review (hey, it's what blogs are for, and I've found that playing coy gets you nowhere) of what beat us:1.
Are You Game? – First up. Mentions Al Gore. Twice. Darn, should have thought of that!
2.
Change the way you think. – Some nice imagery, I guess.
3.
Cheeto and Vinn – OK. Singled-minded and funny. Gets the point across. I’m wishing we’d gone the 60’ option now.
4.
Decisions – Again, not bad imagery. But hard to get ‘into’.
5.
Gaia's Lament – yeah, well. Whatever.
6.
Get Your Green on – And there’s a single out soon, too:)
7.
Green – Nice. Yet one of the lowest ratings so far.
8.
I Did Nothn' – A good line in there somewhere.
9.
Keep it Equal – Nice idea. Neat
editting.
10.
Lights Out – OK, so it’s
campaignable. Worth two in the finals?
11.
Perry the Cockroach – Um, pass.
12.
Plastic Ocean – Nice, simple idea.
13.
Roachie Enviro Contest – If you’re going to use music, it seems it is better if
wra... er... rapped.
14.
Small Changes – I’m just guessing, but I think going with plastic bags would make one a shoe-in.
15.
Small Steps – Sort of cute.
16.
Support Good Hot – Energy – Interestingly, only the first that seems to have had some production money on it. The line
ain’t worth it.
17.
The Bags – OK, and here’s another. I’m sure the
COI will buy it.
18.
The Little Things – Lists are good, too. With a song.
19.
The Sky is Falling – Some more production bucks. Not a bad line. Motivated? Highest rate to date.
20.
Think Again – Yeah, well. The money is coming out now. Where from?
21.
This is not a test –
Yay! Another list!
22.
This is the World – Or... don’t cut a tree down that’s already doing its job. Nice production on low budget, though.
23.
What Can Regular People Do? – Follow more lists. It works in creative
eco ads, anyway.
I still think ours is... was pretty good.
Here's the submission notes:
A simple ad for a simple notion: green IS good, but only if you really think about all aspects very carefully. Many of us have bought into the notion of offsetting the carbon consequences of our lifestyles. And it is certainly better than nothing, But only so long as the initiative is worthy and well run. Some schemes still operate on the basis of planting a tree to achieve a balance that will be unlikely to make itself felt for many years, if at all. And time is of the essence, as tipping points are being talked of in terms of decades. Some of these can of course still be viable and good to support. But, as with all things sold in the name of ‘green’, one needs to always challenge such efforts to justify their environmental value, their envIROI (which is not the same as monetary ROI, as you can make a financial investment in our kids’ future that may not pay back monetarily) before committing hard-earned, and highly useful, funds without thinking, simply to ‘buy-off’ a sense of responsibility for one’s actions. The facts of deforestation and national emissions of the world’s current greatest greenhouse gas polluter are a matter of public record. The logic of where our priorities should lie in this instance, are our own. There will be hurdles, to be sure, and this is of course a plea more for preservation rather than reduction, but we think it is one worth making, to be considered and, if necessary, sensibly debated. Other than a bit of time, this ad cost nothing and used no resources... at all. Which is quite an ideal metaphor for the message being conveyed... IF you think about it! ps: No trees were harmed in the making of this commercial. But a nice weed didn’t make it. Sorry. Maybe I should have been nicer about daft celebs and meaningless platitudes. They were the judges after all. Maybe not so daft to see who it was aimed at.
And now...
YouTube!
Which reminds me, it's the
Green Awards to... night? I entered last year but decided against this ever again having seen who the judges were (for a creative contest - even if it's a people's choice, which I often prefer, there is always
pre-
selection... and
agendas) and what they voted into the finals.
Here's one that may win there (it shows a lady's naught bits, which always helps, if you're being viral.):
http://www.green.tv/brazilian